Constitutional and Legal Basis of Civil Litigation

Civil litigation in Pakistan is rooted not only in the CPC 1908 but also in the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. The Constitution guarantees fundamental rights such as:

• Right to property (Article 23 & 24)
  
• Right to dignity and privacy (Article 14)
  
• Equality before law (Article 25)
  
• Access to justice (implicit in Article 4 and Article 10A)
  

These constitutional rights provide the foundation for civil remedies when an individual’s rights are violated.

Key Laws Governing Civil Litigation

• Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC) – Main procedural law for civil cases.
  
• Contract Act, 1872 – Governs agreements and contractual obligations.
  
• Specific Relief Act, 1877 – Provides remedies like injunctions and specific performance.
  
• Limitation Act, 1908 – Prescribes time limits for filing civil cases.
  
• Succession Act, 1925 – Governs inheritance and succession disputes.
  

Jurisdiction of Civil Courts in Pakistan

Jurisdiction defines which court has the authority to hear a civil case. It is determined by:

1. Territorial Jurisdiction – Based on the location of property or residence of the defendant.
   
2. Pecuniary Jurisdiction – Based on the monetary value of the claim.
   
3. Subject-Matter Jurisdiction – Specific laws may require certain disputes (e.g., family matters) to be heard by special courts.
   

For example:

• A family dispute will go to a Family Court.
  
• A land dispute will usually go to a Civil Judge Court in the relevant district.
  
• High-value commercial disputes may be filed in District Courts or High Courts.
  

Types of Civil Litigation in Pakistan

Civil litigation covers a wide range of disputes, including:

1. Property and Land Disputes

Ownership, possession, and inheritance of land are among the most common civil cases in Pakistan.

2. Family and Matrimonial Matters

Cases involving divorce, child custody, guardianship, dowry, and maintenance are handled by family courts.

3. Contractual and Commercial Disputes

Business-related disputes involving contracts, partnerships, and recovery of dues fall under civil litigation.

4. Money Recovery Suits

A creditor may file a civil suit to recover unpaid loans or business payments.

5. Torts and Compensation

Claims for damages due to negligence, defamation, or breach of duty also form part of civil litigation.

Step-by-Step Civil Litigation Process in Pakistan

Interim Relief and Injunctions

Civil courts in Pakistan can grant temporary relief before final judgment, including:

• Stay Orders – Prevents sale, transfer, or possession of disputed property.
  
• Temporary Injunctions – Stops a party from performing certain actions.
  
• Attachment Orders – Freezes property or assets until final decision.
  

These measures protect parties from irreparable harm during ongoing litigation.

Appeals and Review Process

If a party is dissatisfied with a decision, they can seek further remedies:

1. Appeal – Filed in a higher court against the judgment of a lower court.
   
2. Review Petition – Requests the same court to reconsider its judgment on limited grounds.
   
3. Revision – High Court can revise a case where lower courts acted beyond jurisdiction.
   
4. Supreme Court Appeal – Final remedy available under the Constitution.
   

Structure of Civil Courts in Pakistan

Real-Life Case Example

One of the most debated civil cases in Pakistan involved property disputes in Karachi, where multiple generations contested ownership of valuable commercial land. The case dragged on for over 20 years due to conflicting land records, interim injunctions, and multiple appeals. Finally, the Supreme Court of Pakistan ruled in favor of rightful heirs after verifying documentary evidence.

This illustrates how delays, documentation issues, and multiple appeals complicate civil litigation in Pakistan.

Costs of Civil Litigation

Civil litigation in Pakistan can be expensive due to:

• Court Fees – Proportional to claim value.
  
• Lawyer Fees – Varies by lawyer’s reputation and case complexity.
  
• Administrative Costs – Document verification, witness expenses.
  
• Appeal Costs – Each appeal involves additional fees.
  

For many litigants, these costs create barriers to justice.

Role of Technology in Modern Litigation

Pakistan is slowly adopting digital reforms:

• E-filing of cases in High Courts.
  
• Online cause lists and case status updates.
  
• Video link hearings during COVID-19, paving way for remote hearings.
  

Digital transformation could help reduce delays and improve access to justice.

International Comparison

In countries like the UK or USA, civil litigation is often resolved within 1–2 years, thanks to ADR and technology. In contrast, Pakistan’s civil cases may last 5–15 years, making reforms critical.

Challenges in Civil Litigation in Pakistan

Despite its importance, civil litigation suffers from:

1. Backlog of millions of cases.
   
2. Frequent adjournments and procedural delays.
   
3. Shortage of judges and court staff.
   
4. Corruption and misuse of stay orders.
   
5. Low awareness among citizens.
   

Reforms and Solutions

Reforms needed for improvement include:

• Expanding ADR (mediation, arbitration) to reduce court burden.
  
• Increasing number of judges for faster trials.
  
• Strict timelines for evidence and arguments.
  
• Digitization of land and court records to prevent forgery.
  
• Public legal awareness campaigns.
  

Conclusion

Civil litigation in Pakistan is a vital mechanism for protecting rights, enforcing agreements, and resolving disputes. While it remains complex and time-consuming, reforms in digitalization, ADR, and judicial efficiency promise a brighter future. For individuals and businesses, knowledge of the system, costs, and legal remedies is essential for navigating the courts successfully.

If you are seeking professional assistance, firms like thefirstcallsol provide reliable legal support and guidance in handling civil disputes. Their expertise ensures that individuals and organizations can approach litigation with confidence, making the process more effective and result-oriented.

FAQs